Archive for January 14, 2012

by Michael Doyle (Sacramento Bee)

WASHINGTON — A federal courthouse in Boston and a ranch in California’s San Joaquin Valley present competing faces of the animal rights movement.

One side is peaceful. The other, decidedly, is not. Both can feel the weight of the law and the sting of being called a terrorist.

At the giant Harris Ranch, in western Fresno County, investigators are trying to solve the Jan. 8 arson that damaged 14 tractors and several cattle-hauling trailers. Anonymous animal-rights activists claimed responsibility for the fire.

The Harris Ranch arson was clearly a crime, however it happened. But in a new lawsuit, animal advocates with a far different tactical approach contend that Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein and other lawmakers went too far the last time Congress addressed animal rights activism, in 2006.

“We’re not saying that one can’t punish arson,” attorney Rachel Meeropol said in an interview Friday, “but that’s not what the (2006) law is about. The law reaches far too broadly.”

Meeropol, who’s with the New York-based Center for Constitutional Rights, is representing Minneapolis resident Sarahjane Blum and four other activists in the lawsuit, filed Dec. 15. It argues that the 2006 Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act violates the First Amendment rights of those who want to protest how animals are treated.

Blum, for one, founded, whose advocacy efforts helped persuade the California legislature in 2004 to ban traditional foie gras production. The ban, which blocks the force-feeding of ducks “for the purpose of enlarging the bird’s liver beyond normal size,” takes effect in July.

Under the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act, animal rights advocates may be prosecuted for actions that cause “the loss of any real or personal property … used by an animal enterprise” and for interstate travel that has the “purpose of damaging or interfering with the operations of an animal enterprise.”

The animal-rights advocates’ lawsuit argues that the broadly worded law could be used to prosecute activities such as picketing, if companies lose business or have to pay for extra security because of it.

Blum “was stunned that the ethical, important work that she had devoted her life to had been turned overnight into terrorism,” the lawsuit says, adding that she now curtails advocacy “that risks prosecution” under the law.

The Justice Department hasn’t filed its response.

Lawmakers, though, say tougher laws and stricter penalties are needed to stop zealous activism that evolves into violence. Feinstein, in supporting the 2006 law, cited attempted bombings that targeted a University of California at Los Angeles primate research center and a San Francisco Bay Area pharmaceutical company.

“This legislation is crucial to respond to the expanded scope of terrorist activity,” Feinstein said during Senate debate.

Continue reading

Unlike Western European societies, many Chinese people do not divide animals into the “those we eat” and “those we love” categories; particularly for elderly rural and traditional populations, few if any creatures are loved and all are seen as “food,” including, notoriously, the cats and dogs near and dear to so many Western peoples’ hearts. Encouragingly, an animal rights activist movement has emerged in China to challenge the practice of eating cats and dogs, and in some cases activists have physically intervened to stop trucks carrying these animals to slaughter to liberate their captives from a wretched fate. Indeed, attitudes are rapidly changing throughout China, cats and dogs are ever-more becoming loved household members not food items, and activist groups are growing rapidly and beginning to have real impact throughout the country.

Yet the problem remains significant, as we see below in the case of cats, 4 million of whom are slaughtered and eaten by a fast-growing and modernizing nation of 1.3 billion people.

Cat Cages, Tianjin, China

Robert Slattery at The Daily Activist reports:

“China is currently in debate about the morality of eating cat meat, a tradition for some, and a vile practice for others. Regional paper Nanfang Daily reported an estimated 4 million cats are eaten in the country a year, and the number may be rising due to economic hardships.

Cat isn’t eaten as widely as prejudicial conjecture might have one think, but it does appear in a few traditional dishes, eaten largely by rural eldery populations. In addition, it is eaten to supplement diets in the cold winter months.

Cat meat is not popular with youth though, suggesting a paradigm shift regarding the animal. Mei Zhigang, a professor at Central China Normal University explains that for many now, the cat is no longer simply an animal, but “part of human civilization.” This has resulted in new laws regarding animal welfare and consumption. In fact, trade in cat meat is illegal.

While the issue is grotesque for many Western readers, the consumption of cats solves a significant problem China has with feral cats. In Bejing alone, it is estimated that there is over 200,000 stray cats. These kind of numbers can affect the health of the animals, as well as create a significant environmental impact.

Beyond the moral issue at hand, China’s changing view toward protecting and regulating animals is a good sign in a country known for severe lapses in animal and human rights.”

One finds a far less critical report at the China Daily USA site:

A keeper checks caged cats at a house in Wuhan on Dec 30. The cats are believed to have been sent to South China restaurants or are ready to be on the way. Trucks loaded with caged cats often head to South China in recent years.

WUHAN – In a gloomy and damp single-story house in the rural-urban fringe of the city, hundreds of cats are locked in a foul-smelling room. The terrified animals were rounded up in neighboring provinces, and they will be killed in southern China to end up on dinner tables.

“After gathering a certain number, around 300, the cats will be moved to sell to restaurants in Guangdong province and the Guangxi Zhuang autonomous region,” a ‘guardian’ of the cats surnamed Zhou, told China Daily on Tuesday.

Zhou said, since it is getting cold, people in Guangdong and Guangxi will eat cat meat to supplement their diet.

So his boss opened this cat shipping station on Baishazhou Avenue, Wuhan, in October, and is paying him around 1,000 yuan ($156) a month.

“Sometimes there are 70 or 80 cats a day, other times just 20 or 30,” said Zhou, a 60-year-old man from Xiaogan, Hubei province. He began the job, which was described as a “guardian”, at the end of October. His main task is to watch the cats and load them into trucks.

At the dark site, around 100 cats were packed in cages, nervously nestling against one another.

Most of the cats Zhou handles are the common type, but occasionally there are special breeds, he said.

“But they all cost the same – 10 yuan a kilogram,” Zhou said.

The cats were caught mostly in Anhui and Jiangsu provinces, Zhou said, and all had received the necessary quarantine certificates.

“So everything is in order, I think,” he said. The cats will be sent to South China in several days.

In Guangdong, cat meat is a main ingredient in the traditional dish “dragon (snake), tiger (cat), chicken”, which is said to fortify the body.

“The cats will be sold for more than 160 yuan a kg in restaurants.” Zhou said. His boss recently worked at marketing the meat in Guangxi, because cat meat is currently a hot item there.

In late December, the local Nanfang Daily newspaper reported about 4 million cats are eaten in China in a year, and the number is rising.

“In Guangzhou, cat meat is popular now mostly in restaurants on the outskirts of the city. Most of the cat eaters are older people and old habits die hard,” said Feng Dongmei, a manager of cat and dog welfare at the Animals Asia Foundation (AAF), a non-government charitable foundation in Hong Kong.

Cat dishes are rarely seen on the menus of restaurants downtown, and most young people do not eat them nowadays, she said.

An Xiang, a Chinese lawyer who handles public causes and focuses on animal protection, said trade in cat meat is illegal.

Under the Management of New Food Sources law, enacted by the Ministry of Health in July 2007, food that is not customarily eaten in China should be grouped among new sources of food. Businesses dealing in these foods must obtain special authorization.

The law on new food source safety evaluation procedures, issued subsequently in November 2007, stipulates that food eaten only in a few countries or in a few domestic regions is counted among the new food sources.

“The reality is not that people throughout the world or throughout China customarily eat cat, right?” An Xiang asked. And eating cat is limited in parts of the south, he said.

“As cat meat is a new food source, its production and business operation must abide by strict rules to get the safety certification and permission from the Ministry of Health,” An said.

There are no official statistics on the number of domestic cats in China, because the government does not require cats to be registered.

In Beijing, the number of stray cats has rapidly been increasing in recent years, mainly because more cats are being abandoned by families moving away, said Qin Xiaona, head of the Capital Animal Welfare Association.

By 2007, there were as many as 200,000 stray cats in the capital, she said, citing association’s latest figures.

An animal activist in Beijing, who identified herself as Xiaomiao, said that because it costs less, cat meat is usually mixed with the roasted mutton sold by the roadside in the city.

“Many people don’t know that what they have eaten was cat meat,” she said.

Tu Jiancheng, a professor at the Zhongnan Hospital of Wuhan University, said the cats are carriers of many of pathogens that can cause health problems. “It probably won’t turn out well for people who ate sick cats,” Tu said.

Mei Zhigang, a professor who studies social problems at Central China Normal University, said the cat is not simply an animal, but part of human civilization.

The fate of the cats has triggered growing concern among animal rights activists in the country, and “more people have joined us to prevent cats from being captured and killed,” Xiaomiao said.

In October, with the help of local police, an animal protection organization rescued nearly 200 cats from a dog trader in Wuxi, East China’s Jiangsu province. The cats were to be delivered to restaurants.

China has recently finished a draft on animal protection, and it is singled out as a punishable offense.

Back at the cat station, guardian Zhou said he will leave the job after the Chinese New Year because his grandchildren are unhappy about what he is doing.

Despite the recent vegan self-congratulation festival over reports that meat consumption is down in the US, there is no cause for celebration, for, as usual, vegans ignore the global picture.

According to the new Vital Signs report below, global meat production continues to increase, and “worldwide meat production has tripled since the 1970s … Since 2000, global meat production has risen by 20 percent.”

So don’t break out the champagne; esclate the struggle.

Vital Signs, October 11, 2011:
“Global meat production increased by 2.6 percent in 2010 to 290.6 million tons, an increase from the 0.8 percent growth rate of 2009. (See Figure 1.) Even with this minimal increase, however, worldwide meat production has tripled since the 1970s. The increase continued the steady growth of the past decade. Since 2000, global meat production has risen by 20 percent.

“Meat consumption is also growing worldwide. Per capita meat consumption has increased from 41.3 to 41.9 kilograms.Consumption varies greatly between countries, however. In the developing world, individuals eat about 32 kilograms of meat a year. But consumers in the industrial world eat about 80 kilograms per person each year.

Pork is the most widely produced meat in the world, followed by poultry, beef, and sheep.Total pig meat production increased by about 3 percent in 2010, to 109 million tons.China, which holds nearly half of the world’s pig market, has been affected by an elimination of sow subsidies—the government funds paid farmers to increase hog production—as well as by outbreaks of foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) and swine blue ear disease. Reduced supplies in Asia are expected to translate into record exports by the United States to feed rising demand in traditional Asian markets such as South Korea, China, and Japan.


Fight for me. If I am violently attacked, defend me by any means necessary, as I would do for myself if I could. When I am confined and held captive, do what it takes to free me. If I am being stabbed, poisoned, beaten, or tortured, put away your pretty principles and physically intervene to stop the violence against me. Your “nonviolence” perpetuates violence against me, and is stained with my blood. Think of what I need you to do, not what society and most of my “advocates” say you can do.

%d bloggers like this: